Making virgin drinks that taste like the original drink has it’s challenges. To make a virgin mudslide required a coffee syrup and a home made Irish Cream without the Irish Whiskey. Cut with milk this drink was tasty – but sweet. To make my latest masterpiece the Tidy Bowl Shooter, I used curaçao syrup but cut it with Jamaican Ginger Beer so the sweetness was balanced by spice and fizz. Some shooters though are an epic fail – especially when blending multiple syrups instead of multiple liqueurs. While liqueurs are sweet they also have a kick of alcohol, the syrups… well they are simply sweet. This was most apparent when I tried to use my butterscotch syrup in place of butterscotch schnapps. I tried something called a Butterfly shooter from BarNoneDrinks: half Butterscotch and have Irish Cream right? Well I had both of these – in syrups so it should be a piece of cake! Nope. Thick and utterly impossible to drink – ick. Similarily the pumpkin pie shooter made from Butterscotch Scnapps, Baileys and Goldschlager also doesn’t translate well into a combination of syrups. There is also a similar mix called the oatmeal cookie using vodka and cinnamon schnapps, but again too much syrup and nothing to cut it with.
So how to fix this dilemma?
It occurred to me that one needs to balance the sweet with something, similar to in a cocktail where bitters are used to balance the sweetness. And so far, in other more successful shooters, I have used the addition of a cream, a sour mix or a fizzy spicy addition to balances the sweetness of a syrup based skeeters (virgin shooters).
So what options are left? Salty? More Sour? More Fizz or Spice? Or do some drinks simply not convert to the virgin option no matter how much you want them to?
So there is my dilemma – and my latest challenge.
Sugar and Cloth had one way to meet this challenge. She blends sweet caramel, ice-cream and milk with a dash of salt. What a better way to cut sweetness than cream and salt! You can find her recipe here.
Another option is to relish in the sweetness. There are a ton of shooter recipes that are imitating food. The Oreo Cookie Shooter that blends chocolate, coffee liqueur and Irish cream – all easy enough to replace with syrups to make a strong sweet concoction. So why not serve with a glass of milk just like the cookie, as a chaser? Or to be more creative, invest in some shooter bomb glasses and serve the milk around the shooter – just like a kid would dip his oreo in milk. We tried this recipe with non alcoholic syrups… Tasted nothin’ like an Oreo Cookie – unless you are dipping them into coffee!
So this is just the beginning of my journey – and more experiments are needed – but I am hopeful.